|Israel Resource Review
||16th April, 2001
When the EU Facilitates Israeli Organizations in Support of the Oslo Process
Dr. Daphne Burdman
Psychiatric Research Analyst, Jerusalem, Israel
The Middle East peace process initiated with the Oslo Accords has
attracted many supporters of which the European Union is pre-eminent, with
a financial aid program from the EU and the European Investment Bank
amounting to three billion dollars since 1994.
So said Jean Breteche, Representative of the European Union Commission to
the West Bank and Gaza Strip who is in effect both Ambassador and
administrative officer- coordinator for the E.U. to the Palestinian
Authority (a so-called "developing nation" in the terminology of aid
programs). What is not widely known is that the EU delegation has become
deeply involved in funding Israeli political projects that work closely
with the Palestinian Authority.
I spoke with Mr. Breteche at the European Commission headquarters in the
Sheikh Jarrah Israeli Arab neighborhood of East Jerusalem where a number
of other Representative Offices and Consulates are to be found, among them
the Italian, Swedish and Swiss offices all of which act as liaisons to
the nascent Palestinian Authority
Mr. Breteche defined the mandate of the E.U., to "instill humanitarian
principles, respect for human rights, and the concepts of a viable
democracy". "The EU in Palestine", as he designates what Israel considers
to be the Palestinian Authority, he says "is working predominantly in
two sectors, namely education and health…". He notes that they yet have a
long list of new projects, are by far the most active in supporting
development in Gaza, and are now financing many N.G.O's, including a
variety of agencies that are sponsored under the 'People to People'
program to improve communication between Israelis and Palestinians. Yet
among those agencies one finds a list of political organizations that are
bonafide grass roots left wing Israeli organizations.
For one, Mr Breteche confirmed that Peace Now has been and will continue
to be funded by the EU, and stated that its program would help to create
contact between groups of Israeli and Palestinian people. However Peace
Now is hardly a social work organization or an institute for
reconciliation. Peace Now is a long standing indigenous left wing Israeli
organization which has strongly criticized the Oslo process and the
Israeli government for not demanding the removal of Jewish communities in
Judea, Samaria and Gaza. "Peace Now" takes a political position that Jewish
communities beyond the Green Line are the single most important impediment
In its 1999 report to the European Commission, Peace Now acknowledged that
it had used EU funds for a massive program to reach out to new immigrants
to bring them to their political demonstrations, and to print up their
fliers and pamphlets in several languages .Meanwhile, Peace Now has never
addressed itself to the longstanding issues of human rights abuses or ,
anti-democratic tendencies that permeate the Palestinian Authority, which
would most certainly have been within the purview of the EU's agenda for
human rights and democracy.
Meanwhile, EU Commission in Tel Aviv affirms that the Peace Now program
"Israeli-Palestinian Peace Campaign" will continue to receives ongoing
funds from the EU. The EU is also allocating another 400,000 EURO for
MADA, the political organization that supports the Member of Knesset Roman
Bronfman, the Russian Israeli legislator who broke from Sharansky's
faction shortly after the May 1999 election. A source at the EU wrote that
the EU aims to find ways to encourage newly arrived Russian Jews to
participate in the political activities of Israel's peace movement. When
the Peace Now demonstrations are publicized in European media, this in turn
influences international public opinion including the EU constituency
regarding the settlements, although nowhere in the Declaration of
Principles is there made any mention anywhere of restriction of Israeli
building beyond the green line.
'Mr. Breteche also confirmed that the EU has been supporting the Israeli
Committee Against House Demolitions for the past few years. The record
shows that the EU allocated 250,000 Euro (approximately U.S.$221550)
to this group. which organizes press campaigns and public demonstrations
against the practice of land expropriation and house demolitions by the
Israeli Army,. When asked whether there have been any political
reactions to the funding Mr. Breteche stated that there have not been.
Jeff Halper, the director of the Committee Against House Demolitions,
acknowledged the EU funding and noted that his organization operates under
an umbrella of about fifteen other political organizations, among them
Peace Now. Halper describes the EU as dedicated to "peace education of the
Israeli public". However, Halper
has been known to grossly exaggerated Israeli policy in regard to home
demolitions. claiming that Israel was set to destroy 6,000 homes in
Jerusalem when the number was between 129 and 152. Speaking on March 22 to
an interfaith forum, Halper claimed that the bypass roads in the West Bank
were restricted to Jews only - a falsfified statement. On a recent
lecture tour in the US , Halper described the Israeli government as a
Breteche also confirmed that in the past year the EU had agreed to fund
the program the "Four Mothers Movement to leave Lebanon in Peace".
The program was to have provided a platform for Israeli and Lebanese women
to develop further contacts and understandings after a potential Israeli
However, Breteche noted, since the Israeli withdrawal from Lebanon, funding
the "four mothers" organization was no longer considered by the EU to be
In fact, one wonders why the funding of this project was dropped after
the IDF withdrawal, since the creation of a peaceful ambience in the
border zone was certainly within the mandate of the EU and might have been
strongly advantageous to an ultimate true peace.
Breteche confirmed that among other organizations to be funded by the EU
Commission are the Council on Foreign Relations (CFR), MEILER, Ir Shalem,
and Macon Mifne.
The purpose of the CFR project is for 'Strengthening Palestinian Public
Institutions', a project run by Henry Siegman, a man who has made a career
out of writing anti Israel op-eds for the New York Times and International
Herald Tribune. Breteche referred to Seigman's latest report to the EU
which criticized the P.A, but was vague about whether .it would be ever be
Bretheche confirmed that the EU has also helping to finance the Tel Aviv
based MEILER, The Middle East Center for Legal and Economic Research which
surveys Palestinian refugee real estate holdings throughout Israel.
The project provides precise identification of pre-1948 Arab holdings
throughout Israel, working with a supercomputer funded by the EU and
situated at the Orient House, designed to help Arabs who live in refugee
camps to establish their claims for compensation for property lost in 1948
from 531 Arab villages.
However, a visit to the Orient House clarified that this is also aiding
Arabs in locating, reclaiming, and making actual plans to move back to
these villages, even if they have been replaced by Israeli cities, farms
Breteche also noted the EU role in financing the full costs of legal
services of "Ir Shalem", in its program to stop Israeli government
expansion in East Jerusalem, and to stop the Israeli eviction order of
Palestinian Authority personnel from Orient House, which the Israeli
authorities claimed had been functioning as an illegal P.A. "embassy" in
Breteche confirmed that the EU financed the full cost of the litigation
against Israeli building projects throughout East Jerusalem including Har
Homa, Ras El Amud at the Mount of Olives, and against the purchase of
former Jewish homes in the Moslem quarter of Jerusalem.
Another Israeli grass roots organization of some interest also funded by
the EU is Macon Mifne, which defines its tasks as "education for peace
and democracy of the Jewish settlers and their right wing supporters
within Israel; Yet the founder and operator of Machon Mifne Zvia
Greenfield, has made her name by appearing on regular T.V. and radio talk
shows, while conducting haranguing, scurrilous attacks on the settlers
as the cause of the current Israeli-Palestinian problems. Her capacity for
"conflict resolution" and education of settlers seems lacking indeed.
The common thread of each of these native Israeli groups is that they all
have been able to get a lion's share of media attention, mostly outside
Israel, with the generous help of the EU.
friendly version of this article
Return to Contents
Ha'aretz: IDF 'White Paper' Slams PA Officials
Peres Opposes It
Not Clear If and When It Will Be Released
The Israel Defense Forces has recently completed a new "White Paper," which
criticizes the Palestinian Authority and its chairman, Yasser Arafat. The
document forms a basis for an international information campaign aimed at
undermining the PA's global image.
Foreign Minister Shimon Peres, who learned of the IDF's initiative from
Ha'aretz, is adamantly opposed to the document. His bureau said, "The army's
role is to defend the country, and not to write books or undertake such
Peres discussed the matter with Defense Minister Benjamin Ben-Eliezer, who
said he did not approve of the White Paper or any other such propaganda
campaign against the Palestinians.
The new white paper is an update of a similar document released in November
2000 under the Barak government, and written at the start of the Al-Aqsa
Intifada. The new edition contains many more details of the institutional
and personal corruption of the PA and its officials, as well as
reproductions of inciting articles that have appeared in the PA's media, and
photographs of terrorist attacks carried out since the last edition was
The document also contains a chapter on the PA's abrogation of human rights.
The new White Paper was put together by IDF Colonel Eran Lerman, assistant
to the head of the IDF's manpower research department, Colonel Amos Gilad.
A source in the Prime Minister's Office said yesterday that the document's
date of release would have to be carefully weighed, depending of the
Palestinians' behavior in the immediate future, as well as other factors.
The revelation of the personal corruption within the PA, in particular,
raises a problem, since many PA officials have business links inside Israel.
friendly version of this article
Return to Contents
The View from Katif, South of Gaza
A Jewish Resident of Katif Under Fire
Resident, Neve Dekalim, Katif, South of Gaza
At 6:10 this morning the first mortar shell fell on Neve Dekalim. I and
several others ran out of shul -- amazing how some people will use any
excuse to get out of shul -- but, though the explosion had been very loud,
there was nothing to be seen. Not a minute passed before a second explosion,
somewhat more distant, was heard. Still no clue as to the site. Thirty
seconds later, while we stared at each other in perplexity, the third and
loudest explosion occured. Still no smoke, flying debris, any sign that it
wasn't more than sound effects. For a moment I remembered a "Lights Out!"
radio play from my youth in which a record of a train is played to scare an
elderly couple living near abandoned railroad tracks. Could our
hot-for-peace-partners be doing that to us?
I ran home to find La Passionara, [ed: wife, Rachel] standing in
front of the house. "Are those doors slamming, dear?" she said in her most
sarcastic tones. This was to put me in my place for trying to convince her
on earlier occasions that the loud noises she took for explosions were
merely doors being slammed.
A moment or two later a security jeep came by. The driver said one shell had
fallen in Kfar Yam, a kilometer away, and two shells had fallen in the
outsized petting zoo we have at the entrance to our settlement. I had barely
begun making ill-considered jokes about 'Mourning for Mongoose' and 'Sitting
Shiva for Sheep' when another vehicle pulled up. The driver said he had just
come from the sites of the explosions. I asked about the animals. "What
animals?" he said. "One shell fell on the basketball court in the
schoolyard. The second hit the bus stop outside the school. The third landed
across the road from the guardpost at the entrance to the settlement." He
drove off with a cheery "Now we can hold our heads up. We've been hit, too!"
[As of this writing, 10 a.m., I have no idea where the shells landed. Maybe
they were a fignewton of our imagination?]
At 7, fully forty-five minutes after the third and last bomb, the
loudspeakers came on telling everyone to remain under cover. At 7:20 the
loudspeakers came on again telling us to return to normal. But what is
'normal' for us?
The shelling of Neve Dekalim was the fourth item on this morning's news. The
third was that three mortar shells were fired at IDF checkpoints from the
area of Beit Hanun the IDF evacuated last night, the same area from which
shells had been fired on Sderot. [The first two items concerned shooting in
It is clear, at least to me, that today's shelling is the response to
Israel's craven capitulation to American pressure. The spinmeisters may
pretend that the decision to withdraw was made before American criticism.
This is clearly nonsense. It is difficult to exaggerate the psychological
damage done to us by this withdrawal. I had spent the better part of the
afternoon arguing that our entry into Beit Hanun was a sign that Sharon was
on the right track. The withdrawal showed that if, indeed, Sharon was on the
right track, then he has been derailed.
More than ever it is clear that in the view of the government, and of many
of our fellow citizens, we are a legitimate target for terrorist attacks. We
can expect little in the way of protection, and less in the way of
deterrence of our attackers.
It wouldn't upset me if I came back as a duck in some future life. I just
hadn't expected to be a [sitting] duck in this one.
The writer is an IDF veteran,
handicapped from the Yom Kippur War in 1973
friendly version of this article
Return to Contents
the Israel Resource
The Israel Resource Review is brought to you by
the Israel Resource, a media firm based at the Bet Agron Press Center in
Jerusalem, and the Gaza Media Center under the juristdiction of the Palestine
You can contact us on firstname.lastname@example.org.