|Israel Resource Review
||21st March, 2003
When Reuters Miscaptioned a
Photo, They Changed an Accidental Death into a
A news story which shocked the world this week
dealt with the crushing of American citizen Rachel Corrie by an
IDF bulldozer, who ostensibly blocked with her body a bulldozer
about to demolish the home of a Palestinian terrorist in Gaza,
made huge headlines all over the world. I asked to speak with
the spokesman of International Solidarity Movement Mike Shaik, who
passed me on to Lynn Clausen, a 24-year old resident of Washington from the
Christians Peacemakers Team based in Hebron, which trains the ISM
Shaik and Clausen sent me to speak with Corrie's friends who were with
her at the time she was crushed. Corrie's friend Joe Smith
described me how Corrie sat on a mound of dirt facing the IDF bulldozer
making its way to the house it was about to demolish.
"Rachel had two options", Smith says. "When the bulldozer started to
dig in the dirt pile, the pile started to move, and she could have rolled
sideways quickly or fallen backwards to avoid being hit. But Rachel leaned
forward to climb to the top of the dirt pile. The bulldozer's digging drew
her downward, and its driver could not see her anymore. So without lifting
the scoop, he turned backward and she was already underneath the blade"
Smith's description is very important, since the picture published by
Reuters shows Corrie standing to the left of the bulldozer, in a location
where the driver can see her very clearly, as she holds a megaphone in her
hand. Beneath the picture's caption is written: "Photographed before Rachel
Corrie was run over by an IDF bulldozer." Everyone who looks at the picture
and the text understands that the driver, who sees the American civilian
standing in front of him, just kept on going, crushing her to death. But
Joe Smith says that the picture was taken hours before she was run over,
which happened at 5:00 p.m., and not a few minutes beforehand. Smith
emphasizes that at the time of the incident and during it, there
were no photographers in the area.
After I checked the pictures that Reuters distributed to the world's
newspapers, I noticed the difference between the colors of the sky in the
picture where Corrie stands with the megaphone and the one that shows the
body after the incident. The time the picture was taken also appears in
text on the Internet site, saying that it was in the morning. It is not
noted that the incident took place hours later.
I called Reuters's photography department and asked for an explanation.
The photography editor said that the pictures were not taken by his agency,
which had no photographers in the area at all, and that the pictures came
to them via ISM.
The Reuters photography editor added that he wrote clearly that
the pictures had been taken by ISM.
I pointed out to him that no such notice appeared in the pictures I saw on the Reuters site. I asked the director general of Reuters in Israel, Tim Heritage, whether Reuters has a set policy of using pictures
provided by political organizations, and Heritage replied that it is
Heritage promised into check the matter of the misleading
picture that was taken before the incident and asked me to call him back in an hour.
After an hour, Heritage was no longer available to speak with me. I went
into the Reuters website and was amazed to find that the pictures of Corrie
had been removed.
Thus the American woman who came to protect the homes of Palestinian
terrorists with her own body was wiped out twice: once by an IDF bulldozer
and then by the Reuters agency, which came to "document" the incident.
The damage the agency caused still requires repair. A picture is worth a
thousand words. The picture of Rachel Corrie with the megaphone, standing
before the bulldozer of the "cruel Zionist occupier", who was "crushed
after this picture was taken", as Reuters falsely wrote, will be
engraved in the memories of those who follow events in the Middle East.
[By no strange coincidence, the web site of the International
Solidarity Movement, at www.palsolidarity.org, features the
picture of Rachel Corrie, holding her proverbial megaphone, with
a caption which says that Rachel was in the clear sight of the
bulldozer driver before he ran her over. Yes, five hours
before . . .]
These pictures were sent out by Reuters in sequence, and gave the impression
that Rachel was mauled by the bulldozer after
she had been standing with a megaphone in hand, in clear view of the bulldozer
driver which ran her down.
friendly version of this article
Return to Contents
the Israel Resource
The Israel Resource Review is brought to you by
the Israel Resource, a media firm based at the Bet Agron Press Center in
Jerusalem, and the Gaza Media Center under the juristdiction of the Palestine
You can contact us on firstname.lastname@example.org.